Applying lessons learned - two more keyboard iterations

The journey continues (see previous post for more info...)...  This post is really just for a few folks who had asked for updates.

I have learned a few more lessons:
  • Expect it to take 3-4 months (100-200 hours) per full board build - a long feedback loop is just the nature of the game, especially with my availability
  • Expect to get some crucial feature wrong - design for design failure
  • Expect to break parts or have bad solder joints - design for repair
  • Expect to be tempted to rush things
If you want to follow along or look for more detail or laughs or horror, I keep a build log in a google doc here: It's super long, but often updated daily

What follows is a brief summary of the keyboard development work between July 2022 and April 2023.  I'll leave out the business analogies (continuous improvement aside).  For the curious, the 'mk13' (mark = old British engineering thing, I think?) indicates the thirteenth time I started from scratch - and the maths-inclined amongst whoever reads this might note that 3-4 months times 16 doesn't equal 18 months of me walking these paths - some designs got thrown out real quick-like.

mk13 - the daily driver

I'm typing this post using this board - the ergonomics of it seem to work for me - and indeed it's made it possible to continue working (as I can no longer use a mouse).
  • Thumb trackball positioning improved from mk9, along with auto-mouse
  • Many more keys: 7x6 + 6 thumb keys per side
  • Thumb clusters that don't destroy my thumb tendons
  • Larger palm rests
  • Better use of layers and combinations
  • Screens - why? peer pressure, that's why.  Also was an interesting option for making visible the invisible workings of the firmware.

The outcome?
  • Some teething issues around solder joints...ok a lot of issues with solder joints...
  • The design, in practice, was not 'operable'
  • There was a qmk bug, maybe?, that brought performance issues when using RP2040 and split transport, and/or my firmware/hardware had issues; had to turn off the screens eventually to recoup enough performance
  • But finally, something that would allow me to keep working!  Success.
Except until the one day I messed up a firmware update for it, and realized how fragile my situation was!  So now we need a backup...

mk15 - the 'definitely going to be better' improvement/backup

End of November 2022 through April 2023 produced this...
  • 30-degree tent (BKB's Charybdis as a tracing aid)
  • 4x6 + 6 thumb keys / side
  • Dual trackballs (left = vert/horizontal scroll, right = mouse)
  • Indicator strip at back (colour changing based on stuff like 'shift-hold is on')
  • Encoders change per-layer (left = functions, right = layer select+hold)

The outcome?
  • My symptoms have progressed since the design of this board started; I'm physically unable to use it.
  • Dual encoders (Falcon pcb is great!!) and trackballs are pretty super duper.
  • Dpad is where it's at!! (5-way switch giving directional arrow keys)
  • Learned some lessons around design-for-repair....again...
  • Learned what does NOT work for me! \o/
In the meantime, I have mk13 and mk15 together on my desk, pulling functionality from both!

mk16...er mk17 - seventeenth time's the charm, right?

mk16 was fun, but didn't work out.  Between issues with finding the right lofting look and packaging and realizing that I should use dual encoders/side...well, lessons learned.  Some of the design aspects will transfer over.


mk17 is going to be an improved and more maintainable mk13, with all the lessons of the in-between...we'll see how it pans out.




Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Learning through failure - a keyboard creation journey

Image
tl;dr Built a custom keyboard cuz I have weirdo nerve pain issues.   Learned a lot cuz I failed a lot.   Maybe 'do it right the first time' is a bad frame of mind.   The keyboard ended up being kinda nifty.   It has lights, and a trackball, and QMK, and it helps my issues.   \o/ ( tl;dr is internet lingo that means, too long; didn't read ) Pain as a key ingredient An old proverb says, 'necessity is the mother of invention', and that is how this story begins. Over the last few years, age or stress or something has caught up with me and I developed the need to change my human-to-computer interface.  Mousing changed to trackballing.  The traditional keyboard was swapped out for an ergonomic, and then split keyboard.  Complicated multi-finger-and-hand key combinations were replaced by single keypress macros.  And yet more was still needed. It's often said that change only happens with pain - indeed, the organizations many of us work in seem to apply this as law - an
Read more

Learning Opportunities - Watching/listening list

Over the last year I've spent a lot of time learning (thank you, long commute & lunch hours).  Many topics ranging from Chef to DevOps to architecture concepts to management concepts and everything in between.  Why have I done this? DevOps Demystified with Ben Rockwood: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h5E--QSBVBY DevOps at ancestry.com: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pF5ya0q53kk Those two presentations were key in sending me down this road.  First, and most important, was Mr. Rockwood's explanation as to the real 'why', and the point behind DevOps from an operational perspective.  Second, and no less important but for a different reason, the continuous delivery system at ancestry.com really made it real to me because they are a 'Windows shop'.  So much of what I'd been reading about Chef/config mgmt. relied on amazing tools (see the error there?) only available to the Linux world.  Suddenly here's this guy telling me that it's possible on
Read more

DFSR - eventid 4312 - replication just won't work

This warning isn't documented that well on the googles, so here's some google fodder: You are trying to set up replication for a DFS folder (no existing replication) Source server is 2008R2, 'branch office' server is 2012R2 (I'm moving all our infra to 2012R2) You have no issues getting replication configured You see the DFSR folders get created on the other end, but nothing stages Finally you get EventID 4312: The DFS Replication service failed to get folder information when walking the file system on a journal wrap or loss recovery due to repeated sharing violations encountered on a folder. The service cannot replicate the folder and files in that folder until the sharing violation is resolved.    Additional Information:  Folder: F:\Users$\user.name\Desktop\Random Folder Name\  Replicated Folder Root: F:\Users$  File ID: {00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000000}-v0  Replicated Folder Name: Users  Replicated Folder ID: 33F0449D-5E67-4DA1-99A
Read more